Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 1,287 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 245,312
Pageviews Today: 328,023Threads Today: 97Posts Today: 1,460
02:47 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects

 
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 05:09 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Okay, before I start, for the tl;dr's out there, is this just Starlink? I can't find a video of what we saw. But if you know of a Starlink video that shows star like objects flashing on and off at irregular rhythms, and moving about in the sky, that would be GREAT!

Now the full question:

I was just with the fam, exploring some new fishing spots. We fished this creek in the afternoon, then made a mad dash to a nearby lake to try to get the sunset bite.

Didn't catch anything, sun went down, moon wasn't up. Walked all the way back to the car for sandwich dinner (skunked, no fish!) We were going to have a fire on the beach, but fire risk was extreme, so no fires.

We just set up some chairs in the "parking lot" and ate our cold sandwiches. There was no one out there, and we were in DEEP country. Closest somewhat major city was 2 hours away, all others were greater than 6 hours away. Deep Country. So there was no light pollution. We were at 10,000 ft. Crystal clear night, not a cloud in the sky.

We were sitting in COMPLETE darkness for quite a while, cracking jokes, and being just mesmerized by the crystal dome. The Milky Sea was on full display. Huge star count. You must know the kind of night, the night that is so star bright, you know why it is referred to as a "firmament."

This was after the peak of the Perseid meteor shower. But we were seeing shooting stars galore! Some very long, even one that was yellow-orange. That's a new one by me.

We were watching satellites zip around the sky.

Anyway, I started to notice little flashes. They looked like, there was a small black gap in the stars, then something that looked exactly like a star would flash, then disappear. It KIND of looked like an intermittent light on an airplane, but it wasn't that small, these flashes looked just like big stars - you know how they are large, bright, and spiky? Also, the flashes were not regular. At first, I'd see one flash, in one part of the sky. Then nothing there. Then I'd see a flash in another part of the sky. Then nothing there. I didn't mention this, as I'm the only dude in my family, didn't want to spook the ladies. But I kept seeing them.

So I asked if anybody had seen them? They laughed at me. I'm losing my faculties, you see. They said I was crazy and seeing things.

Then, they all, one at a time, started saying they saw one, too.

Once others confirmed they were seeing them too, I figured I probably was not just having a spell. So, they had to be real, the only thing I could think of was that they were meteors coming straight towards us, and burning up. Like, their trajectory was from the direction in space we were looking at, and the meteor came straight at us, burning up in the atmosphere. I don't know if I'm doing a great job of explaining this... I'd never seen this before, so I thought it rather strange to suddenly see such a phenomenon and with such regularity, so I doubted my hypothesis.

Then, I saw one star flash on, several times in the SAME place in the sky. Everyone missed it, as they'd look away right before it'd flash again. This was a bright one. I saw it flash several times in the same place, then it seemed to stop.

BUT then, we all started to see the same flashes. It was me and one of my kids (recently became an adult) at first, we both said, "THERE!" and pointed almost straight ahead, and up about 20-30 degrees from the assumed horizon, there were lumps of mountains and trees in front of us. And then a minute or so later, it flashed again in ALMOST the same spot, then three of us said, "THERE!" Then it flashed a little while later, and all four of us said, "THERE!" So, all of us were seeing it. This thing was completely irregular. It could be 1-2 minutes between flashes. And sometimes, the flash was not focused in a single dot, but kind of seemed that it was like a penny at arm's length sized bright, but, diffuse cloud. This thing moved around. It didn't move on a diagonal across the sky. It moved in a small sort of reverse C, but the C was rotated 60 degrees clockwise, and stretched out a bit, so the ends of the C weren't so curved. Like an open sort of C.

So... WHAT THE HECK WERE THESE OBJECTS OR FLASHES? Some of them were the brightest star in the sky. Jupiter and Saturn, off course, were in the southern sky. These flashes were brighter than Jupiter, by far.

Then I remembered Starlink. I've never seen anything like this before, and I've seen some starlink videos on youtube, and I haven't seen anything that looks like what we saw.

Please, I'm not larping, or anything like that, I'm not trying to deceive, or push an agenda. I'd just like to know what these flashes were.

Thanks all, and I suppose a pin wouldn't hurt to get his attention in the AM. Forget, or don't, didn't ever know (same thing nowadays) what coast he's on, or where he is at all.

But A pin would help him see this, and I'm really curious. If anyone else know what this could be, please let me, and US know!

And if you think it is Starlink, can you link to a video that shows the type of phenomena I'm talking about?

Thanks y'all!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79016557
Canada
08/21/2020 05:12 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
tl;dr

Starlink is a straight line of solid white lights travelling at at a consistent rate of speed.

I have seen Starlink and I have seen "intermittent flashing star like objects." They aren't the same thing.
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 05:21 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
tl;dr

Starlink is a straight line of solid white lights travelling at at a consistent rate of speed.

I have seen Starlink and I have seen "intermittent flashing star like objects." They aren't the same thing.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79016557


Yeah, this definitely wasn't a series of bright dots in a line.

These were discrete "objects" as one flashed a few times from almost the same place, but then traced that C shape I mentioned. Flashing... I don't know, 30 seconds up to 2 minutes apart. And sometimes, more as a diffuse cloud.

The first "light" I saw flashing consistently, (rather than random single flashes around the sky) seemed to flash nearly exactly in the same place, then a few diffuse flashes, and then a few moved slightly.

What do you think the flashing lights you've seen are?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 71408772
United States
08/21/2020 05:32 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Satellites. When they hit the sun just right they sort of flash. It's brief, lasting only a second or two. Not necessarily starlink.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79253285
Sweden
08/21/2020 05:37 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
ALIUMS.

bert-TIAll
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79207921
United Kingdom
08/21/2020 05:38 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
we call it twinkling.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 78206634
United States
08/21/2020 05:39 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
you may be seeing them in your blind spot (about 15* off center each eye)
It's actually my favorite way to show people where it is
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79207921
United Kingdom
08/21/2020 05:40 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
tl;dr

Starlink is a straight line of solid white lights travelling at at a consistent rate of speed.

I have seen Starlink and I have seen "intermittent flashing star like objects." They aren't the same thing.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79016557


no, that's only what startlink looked like before they were deployed to their final locations.

they are now scattered in a net around the globe, not in a straight line, like they were when they were launched.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79145272
08/21/2020 06:06 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
D
I
P
S
H
I
T
You are my sunshine 1210

User ID: 35046531
United States
08/21/2020 06:35 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Okay, before I start, for the tl;dr's out there, is this just Starlink? I can't find a video of what we saw. But if you know of a Starlink video that shows star like objects flashing on and off at irregular rhythms, and moving about in the sky, that would be GREAT!

Now the full question:

I was just with the fam, exploring some new fishing spots. We fished this creek in the afternoon, then made a mad dash to a nearby lake to try to get the sunset bite.

Didn't catch anything, sun went down, moon wasn't up. Walked all the way back to the car for sandwich dinner (skunked, no fish!) We were going to have a fire on the beach, but fire risk was extreme, so no fires.

We just set up some chairs in the "parking lot" and ate our cold sandwiches. There was no one out there, and we were in DEEP country. Closest somewhat major city was 2 hours away, all others were greater than 6 hours away. Deep Country. So there was no light pollution. We were at 10,000 ft. Crystal clear night, not a cloud in the sky.

We were sitting in COMPLETE darkness for quite a while, cracking jokes, and being just mesmerized by the crystal dome. The Milky Sea was on full display. Huge star count. You must know the kind of night, the night that is so star bright, you know why it is referred to as a "firmament."

This was after the peak of the Perseid meteor shower. But we were seeing shooting stars galore! Some very long, even one that was yellow-orange. That's a new one by me.

We were watching satellites zip around the sky.

Anyway, I started to notice little flashes. They looked like, there was a small black gap in the stars, then something that looked exactly like a star would flash, then disappear. It KIND of looked like an intermittent light on an airplane, but it wasn't that small, these flashes looked just like big stars - you know how they are large, bright, and spiky? Also, the flashes were not regular. At first, I'd see one flash, in one part of the sky. Then nothing there. Then I'd see a flash in another part of the sky. Then nothing there. I didn't mention this, as I'm the only dude in my family, didn't want to spook the ladies. But I kept seeing them.

So I asked if anybody had seen them? They laughed at me. I'm losing my faculties, you see. They said I was crazy and seeing things.

Then, they all, one at a time, started saying they saw one, too.

Once others confirmed they were seeing them too, I figured I probably was not just having a spell. So, they had to be real, the only thing I could think of was that they were meteors coming straight towards us, and burning up. Like, their trajectory was from the direction in space we were looking at, and the meteor came straight at us, burning up in the atmosphere. I don't know if I'm doing a great job of explaining this... I'd never seen this before, so I thought it rather strange to suddenly see such a phenomenon and with such regularity, so I doubted my hypothesis.

Then, I saw one star flash on, several times in the SAME place in the sky. Everyone missed it, as they'd look away right before it'd flash again. This was a bright one. I saw it flash several times in the same place, then it seemed to stop.

BUT then, we all started to see the same flashes. It was me and one of my kids (recently became an adult) at first, we both said, "THERE!" and pointed almost straight ahead, and up about 20-30 degrees from the assumed horizon, there were lumps of mountains and trees in front of us. And then a minute or so later, it flashed again in ALMOST the same spot, then three of us said, "THERE!" Then it flashed a little while later, and all four of us said, "THERE!" So, all of us were seeing it. This thing was completely irregular. It could be 1-2 minutes between flashes. And sometimes, the flash was not focused in a single dot, but kind of seemed that it was like a penny at arm's length sized bright, but, diffuse cloud. This thing moved around. It didn't move on a diagonal across the sky. It moved in a small sort of reverse C, but the C was rotated 60 degrees clockwise, and stretched out a bit, so the ends of the C weren't so curved. Like an open sort of C.

So... WHAT THE HECK WERE THESE OBJECTS OR FLASHES? Some of them were the brightest star in the sky. Jupiter and Saturn, off course, were in the southern sky. These flashes were brighter than Jupiter, by far.

Then I remembered Starlink. I've never seen anything like this before, and I've seen some starlink videos on youtube, and I haven't seen anything that looks like what we saw.

Please, I'm not larping, or anything like that, I'm not trying to deceive, or push an agenda. I'd just like to know what these flashes were.

Thanks all, and I suppose a pin wouldn't hurt to get his attention in the AM. Forget, or don't, didn't ever know (same thing nowadays) what coast he's on, or where he is at all.

But A pin would help him see this, and I'm really curious. If anyone else know what this could be, please let me, and US know!

And if you think it is Starlink, can you link to a video that shows the type of phenomena I'm talking about?

Thanks y'all!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 66594553


I have seen that bright flashing too! I'm not sure what it is. Its not a plane, it's not a star. I first thought it wss a plane, but it would only flash once, sometimes twice, but not in a line like a plane. Spontaneous in the sky , not where you would guess it's trajectory. I love looking up at the sky at night. You can see some amazing things. Some just unexplainable. I grew up in the city. We were lucky to see 3 stars at night. We would have to go to the planetarium to see stars and constellations. I hope someone can help you with what they are, I'm curious too!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79289053
Netherlands
08/21/2020 06:37 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
When thunder makes no sounds it means it doesn't have volume?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 73960537
United States
08/21/2020 06:38 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
All I know is the stuff in the sky hasnt been the same since 2012. Everything is multicolored and vibrating/flashing.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79289053
Netherlands
08/21/2020 06:40 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Reminds of that movie war of the world's and the car transformator getting changed resulting in a highway demolshment that doesn't work, cause it's progress.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 76654640
United States
08/21/2020 06:41 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Space monsters and atmospheric beasts. They're akin to giant illuminated jellyfish that float through space.
I see them all the time
User ID: 76376146
United States
08/21/2020 06:44 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Is this what you're talking about?

Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79287593
Hungary
08/21/2020 06:47 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Okay, before I start, for the tl;dr's out there, is this just Starlink? I can't find a video of what we saw. But if you know of a Starlink video that shows star like objects flashing on and off at irregular rhythms, and moving about in the sky, that would be GREAT!

Now the full question:

I was just with the fam, exploring some new fishing spots. We fished this creek in the afternoon, then made a mad dash to a nearby lake to try to get the sunset bite.

Didn't catch anything, sun went down, moon wasn't up. Walked all the way back to the car for sandwich dinner (skunked, no fish!) We were going to have a fire on the beach, but fire risk was extreme, so no fires.

We just set up some chairs in the "parking lot" and ate our cold sandwiches. There was no one out there, and we were in DEEP country. Closest somewhat major city was 2 hours away, all others were greater than 6 hours away. Deep Country. So there was no light pollution. We were at 10,000 ft. Crystal clear night, not a cloud in the sky.

We were sitting in COMPLETE darkness for quite a while, cracking jokes, and being just mesmerized by the crystal dome. The Milky Sea was on full display. Huge star count. You must know the kind of night, the night that is so star bright, you know why it is referred to as a "firmament."

This was after the peak of the Perseid meteor shower. But we were seeing shooting stars galore! Some very long, even one that was yellow-orange. That's a new one by me.

We were watching satellites zip around the sky.

Anyway, I started to notice little flashes. They looked like, there was a small black gap in the stars, then something that looked exactly like a star would flash, then disappear. It KIND of looked like an intermittent light on an airplane, but it wasn't that small, these flashes looked just like big stars - you know how they are large, bright, and spiky? Also, the flashes were not regular. At first, I'd see one flash, in one part of the sky. Then nothing there. Then I'd see a flash in another part of the sky. Then nothing there. I didn't mention this, as I'm the only dude in my family, didn't want to spook the ladies. But I kept seeing them.

So I asked if anybody had seen them? They laughed at me. I'm losing my faculties, you see. They said I was crazy and seeing things.

Then, they all, one at a time, started saying they saw one, too.

Once others confirmed they were seeing them too, I figured I probably was not just having a spell. So, they had to be real, the only thing I could think of was that they were meteors coming straight towards us, and burning up. Like, their trajectory was from the direction in space we were looking at, and the meteor came straight at us, burning up in the atmosphere. I don't know if I'm doing a great job of explaining this... I'd never seen this before, so I thought it rather strange to suddenly see such a phenomenon and with such regularity, so I doubted my hypothesis.

Then, I saw one star flash on, several times in the SAME place in the sky. Everyone missed it, as they'd look away right before it'd flash again. This was a bright one. I saw it flash several times in the same place, then it seemed to stop.

BUT then, we all started to see the same flashes. It was me and one of my kids (recently became an adult) at first, we both said, "THERE!" and pointed almost straight ahead, and up about 20-30 degrees from the assumed horizon, there were lumps of mountains and trees in front of us. And then a minute or so later, it flashed again in ALMOST the same spot, then three of us said, "THERE!" Then it flashed a little while later, and all four of us said, "THERE!" So, all of us were seeing it. This thing was completely irregular. It could be 1-2 minutes between flashes. And sometimes, the flash was not focused in a single dot, but kind of seemed that it was like a penny at arm's length sized bright, but, diffuse cloud. This thing moved around. It didn't move on a diagonal across the sky. It moved in a small sort of reverse C, but the C was rotated 60 degrees clockwise, and stretched out a bit, so the ends of the C weren't so curved. Like an open sort of C.

So... WHAT THE HECK WERE THESE OBJECTS OR FLASHES? Some of them were the brightest star in the sky. Jupiter and Saturn, off course, were in the southern sky. These flashes were brighter than Jupiter, by far.

Then I remembered Starlink. I've never seen anything like this before, and I've seen some starlink videos on youtube, and I haven't seen anything that looks like what we saw.

Please, I'm not larping, or anything like that, I'm not trying to deceive, or push an agenda. I'd just like to know what these flashes were.

Thanks all, and I suppose a pin wouldn't hurt to get his attention in the AM. Forget, or don't, didn't ever know (same thing nowadays) what coast he's on, or where he is at all.

But A pin would help him see this, and I'm really curious. If anyone else know what this could be, please let me, and US know!

And if you think it is Starlink, can you link to a video that shows the type of phenomena I'm talking about?

Thanks y'all!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 66594553


Know nothing about stars - just want to congratulate you on having a real life in this nonsensical world!
beeches

User ID: 78973486
United States
08/21/2020 08:41 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
When thunder makes no sounds it means it doesn't have volume?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79289053


the sound of one cloud clapping eh
Liberalism is totalitarianism with a human face – Thomas Sowell
beeches

User ID: 78973486
United States
08/21/2020 08:42 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Reminds of that movie war of the world's and the car transformator getting changed resulting in a highway demolshment that doesn't work, cause it's progress.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79289053


or a work in progress
Liberalism is totalitarianism with a human face – Thomas Sowell
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 75922698
Australia
08/21/2020 08:51 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Okay, before I start, for the tl;dr's out there, is this just Starlink? I can't find a video of what we saw. But if you know of a Starlink video that shows star like objects flashing on and off at irregular rhythms, and moving about in the sky, that would be GREAT!

Now the full question:

I was just with the fam, exploring some new fishing spots. We fished this creek in the afternoon, then made a mad dash to a nearby lake to try to get the sunset bite.

Didn't catch anything, sun went down, moon wasn't up. Walked all the way back to the car for sandwich dinner (skunked, no fish!) We were going to have a fire on the beach, but fire risk was extreme, so no fires.

We just set up some chairs in the "parking lot" and ate our cold sandwiches. There was no one out there, and we were in DEEP country. Closest somewhat major city was 2 hours away, all others were greater than 6 hours away. Deep Country. So there was no light pollution. We were at 10,000 ft. Crystal clear night, not a cloud in the sky.

We were sitting in COMPLETE darkness for quite a while, cracking jokes, and being just mesmerized by the crystal dome. The Milky Sea was on full display. Huge star count. You must know the kind of night, the night that is so star bright, you know why it is referred to as a "firmament."

This was after the peak of the Perseid meteor shower. But we were seeing shooting stars galore! Some very long, even one that was yellow-orange. That's a new one by me.

We were watching satellites zip around the sky.

Anyway, I started to notice little flashes. They looked like, there was a small black gap in the stars, then something that looked exactly like a star would flash, then disappear. It KIND of looked like an intermittent light on an airplane, but it wasn't that small, these flashes looked just like big stars - you know how they are large, bright, and spiky? Also, the flashes were not regular. At first, I'd see one flash, in one part of the sky. Then nothing there. Then I'd see a flash in another part of the sky. Then nothing there. I didn't mention this, as I'm the only dude in my family, didn't want to spook the ladies. But I kept seeing them.

So I asked if anybody had seen them? They laughed at me. I'm losing my faculties, you see. They said I was crazy and seeing things.

Then, they all, one at a time, started saying they saw one, too.

Once others confirmed they were seeing them too, I figured I probably was not just having a spell. So, they had to be real, the only thing I could think of was that they were meteors coming straight towards us, and burning up. Like, their trajectory was from the direction in space we were looking at, and the meteor came straight at us, burning up in the atmosphere. I don't know if I'm doing a great job of explaining this... I'd never seen this before, so I thought it rather strange to suddenly see such a phenomenon and with such regularity, so I doubted my hypothesis.

Then, I saw one star flash on, several times in the SAME place in the sky. Everyone missed it, as they'd look away right before it'd flash again. This was a bright one. I saw it flash several times in the same place, then it seemed to stop.

BUT then, we all started to see the same flashes. It was me and one of my kids (recently became an adult) at first, we both said, "THERE!" and pointed almost straight ahead, and up about 20-30 degrees from the assumed horizon, there were lumps of mountains and trees in front of us. And then a minute or so later, it flashed again in ALMOST the same spot, then three of us said, "THERE!" Then it flashed a little while later, and all four of us said, "THERE!" So, all of us were seeing it. This thing was completely irregular. It could be 1-2 minutes between flashes. And sometimes, the flash was not focused in a single dot, but kind of seemed that it was like a penny at arm's length sized bright, but, diffuse cloud. This thing moved around. It didn't move on a diagonal across the sky. It moved in a small sort of reverse C, but the C was rotated 60 degrees clockwise, and stretched out a bit, so the ends of the C weren't so curved. Like an open sort of C.

So... WHAT THE HECK WERE THESE OBJECTS OR FLASHES? Some of them were the brightest star in the sky. Jupiter and Saturn, off course, were in the southern sky. These flashes were brighter than Jupiter, by far.

Then I remembered Starlink. I've never seen anything like this before, and I've seen some starlink videos on youtube, and I haven't seen anything that looks like what we saw.

Please, I'm not larping, or anything like that, I'm not trying to deceive, or push an agenda. I'd just like to know what these flashes were.

Thanks all, and I suppose a pin wouldn't hurt to get his attention in the AM. Forget, or don't, didn't ever know (same thing nowadays) what coast he's on, or where he is at all.

But A pin would help him see this, and I'm really curious. If anyone else know what this could be, please let me, and US know!

And if you think it is Starlink, can you link to a video that shows the type of phenomena I'm talking about?

Thanks y'all!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 66594553


Ive seen them they respond to a lazerpen and yes i know lazerpens only travel a few miles
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 75922698
Australia
08/21/2020 08:53 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
All I know is the stuff in the sky hasnt been the same since 2012. Everything is multicolored and vibrating/flashing.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 73960537


Thats not all you know you also know how to say all you know ,use internet etc
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79033813
Brazil
08/21/2020 09:12 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Yes, saw them. I live in a rural area, away from city lights and see them fairly often. One day I observed one carefully and the flashes had an interval of about 18secs. In this time it barely moved, but moved at a consistent rate of speed and in a straight line. This one I think was some rotating space debris at a very high orbit.
But then are those flashes which occur only once and are very bright. These are a mystery.
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 10:21 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
Satellites. When they hit the sun just right they sort of flash. It's brief, lasting only a second or two. Not necessarily starlink.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 71408772


We saw plenty of satellites, slow moving dots of light, steadily moving across the sky.

Seen them since the early 80's. More now of course.

These intermittent flashing star lights would remain in the same location for a while, or the same general location, then this one persistent one moved in a C shape over maybe 10 minutes, through about 5 degrees.

Do we have satellites that are catching the light just right every now and again, in no particular pattern, and driving around, not in an orbit?

I'd like to know what satellites can do that? Do you have a reference? All the satellite tracking pages I'm aware of show satellites in stable orbits.
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 10:25 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
ALIUMS.

bert-TIAll
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79253285


I'm thinking Humiums.
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 10:35 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
we call it twinkling.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79207921


I think maybe you should start putting fluoride in your national water supply or something.

stopposting1

I'm well aware of what twinkling stars look like, I was just under the diamond encrusted dome of wonder, and it was all a twinkling.

This is something completely different.

This is a completely black section of space, then suddenly there will flash, as bright as the brightest star, a star shaped object, and it will disappear as quickly as it came.

Some of these stayed in the same place. Some stayed in the same general space, but flashing from several different positions over time at irregular intervals, and others first stayed in the same place, then flashed about in a general area, then flashed over time the shape of an elongated C, like this -> C but with the ends of the C bent further away from each other.

That is not a twinkling star, you utter fucking wanker.

specialstupid
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 10:58 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
you may be seeing them in your blind spot (about 15* off center each eye)
It's actually my favorite way to show people where it is
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 78206634


I wish people read the original post.

I wrote at length, not just for fun, but to describe this phenomenon. I fell asleep about 20 times writing it, it was so late, and I was so tired!

While I was seeing these flashes, I didn't mention it to anyone, thought I was maybe passing out or something.

Then I told everyone, and they were making jokes at my expense. Then two of us saw it at the same time. I think three of us ended up seeing that one.

Then there was this one basically right in front of us, and we all saw it, and we all called out when in flashed.

I've been looking up at the stars my whole life, only a hundred nights like this, the "diamond dome" type night sky that is bright just from the starts, without a moon. Some of those were on the east coast on mountain tops. But no mountain back east compares to out here in the mountainous regions. 10,000 feet is up there!

I've never seen anything like this before, my wife who grew up in a city has only experienced 20-30 nights like this, though this was definitely close to the furthest we've been from light pollution. I'm telling you, we were a long way away from anything.

I didn't stay up writing about this because the stars were twinkling, and I didn't write about starts falling into and out of my blind spot.

I've never seen anything like this. We all have never seen anything like it. One of my adult children has seen many of these nights, grew up under these very skys. My other child who is almost an adult, has seen many such nights. None of us has ever seen anything like this.

I assumed it was Starlink related, as that is new, and I'd heard, probably on a thread here about starlink causing problems for astronomers, which I could see happening, if they're trained on some dark patch of the sky, and all of a sudden one of these flashing things starts hovering around and clouding up their images.

And speaking of clouding up... some of the flashes were less than distinct. They were more like about a penny at arms reach (if you're 6'2") in size, and just a diffuse glow, again, the sky was cloudless, and dry, we were at 10,000 feet.

I'd really like to know what these were, from some serious people, as I'm seriously asking.

I've never seen anything like this. I've seen some strange things in the sky before, but never anything like this.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 79033813
Brazil
08/21/2020 12:52 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
The big red flag is the trajectory not being a straight line. Objects in orbit, be it satellites or space junk, only follow a rectilinear path due to inertia. To change direction, there must be lateral forces applied (any kind of thrust). Satellites, as far as i know, have small thrusters just enough to make small corrections to their orbits, not to make big maneuvers like You described.
Stumpknocker

User ID: 76451932
United States
08/21/2020 01:10 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
I live in the country and have noticed thai too and thought i was going nuts!

My son has now noticed them as well. Oftentimes they are in my peripheral vision. I look over and say to myself...what was that?

Strange phenomenon indeed. I dont remeber seeing this as a kid growing up in Northern Michigan.

Last Edited by Stumpknocker on 08/21/2020 01:10 PM
"I have never understood why it is greed to want to keep the money you've earned, but not greed to want to take somebody else's money"-- Thomas Sowell

The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 78850661
United States
08/21/2020 01:15 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
We saw the same thing last evening in PA.. my boyfriend and I watch the stars whenever we can
We saw the same bright flashing thing..moving slightly but not a consistent flash..













uote:Anonymous Coward 66594553:MV80NDk2MDc1XzgxOTAwOTcxXzQwQkUzNzM1]
tl;dr

Starlink is a straight line of solid white lights travelling at at a consistent rate of speed.

I have seen Starlink and I have seen "intermittent flashing star like objects." They aren't the same thing.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 79016557


Yeah, this definitely wasn't a series of bright dots in a line.

These were discrete "objects" as one flashed a few times from almost the same place, but then traced that C shape I mentioned. Flashing... I don't know, 30 seconds up to 2 minutes apart. And sometimes, more as a diffuse cloud.

The first "light" I saw flashing consistently, (rather than random single flashes around the sky) seemed to flash nearly exactly in the same place, then a few diffuse flashes, and then a few moved slightly.

What do you think the flashing lights you've seen are?
Anonymous Coward (OP)
User ID: 66594553
United States
08/21/2020 03:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
I live in the country and have noticed thai too and thought i was going nuts!

My son has now noticed them as well. Oftentimes they are in my peripheral vision. I look over and say to myself...what was that?

Strange phenomenon indeed. I dont remeber seeing this as a kid growing up in Northern Michigan.
 Quoting: Stumpknocker


That's how it started that night. I was seeing them in my peripheral vision. I thought I was going crazy (as I do have some neuro damage). But then I started to catch some full on.

And when we were sitting, that's when I told everybody what I was seeing. Chuckles, then everyone else started to see them. And we'd all see them at the same time.

If you see one, just stop what you are doing, and keep looking at that spot of the night sky. It is likely it will flash from there, or close to there again. That's how I went from randomly seeing them to actually repeatedly seeing them.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 31259181
United States
08/21/2020 03:34 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
You're not crazy, I made a thread about a month ago and so have others. I started noticing it around May or so. At first I thought it was plane strobes but have observed them now enough to see its not. And no it's not star link. I've seen that and it kinda pisses me off like night sky pollution. You'll catch some out of the corner of your eye and some dead on. I dunno wtf it is,. Anyways you're not crazy OP. Not with this anyways lol
ProfessorDweeb
User ID: 79177071
United States
08/21/2020 03:49 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Astro question - strange intermittent flashing star like objects
I read your entire post. I too have seen the same phenomenon and only recently. Here is my brief documentation from another thread last week.
I too saw some strange things tonight. One was sky flashes, likely heat lightning. (No clouds in sight, butThere was a storm about 150 miles away )

Secondly, I saw a series of localized flashes in the same spot spaced about maybe 5-7 seconds apart. I first saw a pinpoint flash in my periferal and shifted my focus to the spot. I saw a bright blaze wink out. No tail. I assumed I was lucky enough to see one of those “coming right at you” meteors. Even let out a awe struck “wow”.Then it happened again... again.... again.... again.... again... again in the same spot. 1 of the top 3 most interesting things i’ve Seen in the sky.
 Quoting: ProfessorDweeb 79185636





GLP